Jump to content
IObit Forum
Top Free Driver Updater Tools Best 25 PC Optimization Software Best 22 Antimalware Best 22 Uninstaller Software IObit Coupons & Discount Offers PC Optimizer Mac Boost Advice IObit Coupons A Good Utility Program From IObit IObit Promo Codes IObit Coupon Codes IObit Coupons and Deals FAQs Driver Booster Pro Review

[3.Bi-Weekly]Comparative analysis IObit Security 360 and Ad-aware (FREE)

serginian

By serginian
in Test & Vote ----[Test is over]

Recommended Posts

serginian Newbie

serginian

Posted
Posted

Comparative analysis IObit Security 360 and Ad-aware (FREE)

1. The Test was lead on my old computer - Sempron 2600 + (1.3 Gb RAM). Location - Latvia.

1.1 The important element, on what it is necessary to pay attention, it is size of an instal file:

IObit Security 360 weighs 8,5Mb and Ad-aware (FREE) weighs 58Mb.

[+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 1/10]

1.2 In established kind IObit 360 weighs 26 Mb, and Ad-aware whole 60Mb.

[+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 2/10]

2.1 The Size of the first loaded up-date package at IObit 360, borrows nearby 500Kb, and at Ad-aware free, more 1,5Mb.

[+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 3/10]

2.2 The up-date package at IObit Security 360 It was loaded less than 5 seconds. And at Ad-aware free, up-date borrows about one minute. [+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 4/10]

 

3. Speed of scanning at IObit Security 360 (Smart scan) ~3 min. Speed of scanning at Ad-aware free (Smart scan) ~13 min. [+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 5/10]

3.1 Speed of scanning at IObit Security 360 (Full scan) ~16 min. Speed of scanning at Ad-aware free (Full Scan) nearby 56 min. [+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 6/10]

4.1 Quality of scanning IObit Security 360 (Smart Scan) - is found 3 threats (Tracking cookies). Ad-aware free (Smart Scan) - 4 threats (Tracking cookies) are found. [+1 to estimation AD-Aware FREE - total 1/10]

Here is a log file of scanning:

AD_AWARE

Scan profile name: Smart Scan (ID: smart)

Objects scanned: 31291

Objects detected: 4

 

 

Type Detected

==========================

Processes.......: 0

Registry entries: 0

Hostfile entries: 0

Files...........: 0

Folders.........: 0

LSPs............: 0

Cookies.........: 4

Browser hijacks: 0

MRU objects.....: 0

 

 

 

Skipped items:

Description: *atdmt* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 408910 Family ID: 0

Description: *doubleclick* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 408875 Family ID: 0

Description: *hit.gemius* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 409369 Family ID: 0

Description: *2o7* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 408943 Family ID: 0

 

 

IOBIT SECURITY 360

IObit Security 360

 

OS: Windows XP

Version: 1.0.0.60

Define Version: 1211

Time Elapsed: 00:03:13

Objects Scanned: 59723

Threats Found: 3 {@doubleclick.net <mailto: % 7b@doubleclick.net> (*doubleclick *), @atdmt.com (*atdmt *), @msnportal.112.2o7.net (*2o7 *)}

 

 

 

4.2 Quality of scanning IObit Security 360 (Full Scan) - is found 4 threats (2 Tracking cookies + Adware + Trojan). Ad-aware free (Full Scan) 2 threats (Tracking cookies) are found. [+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 7/10]

Here is a log file of scanning:

 

AD_AWARE

Scan profile name: Full Scan (ID: full)

Objects scanned: 162365

Objects detected: 2

 

 

Type Detected

==========================

Processes.......: 0

Registry entries: 0

Hostfile entries: 0

Files...........: 0

Folders.........: 0

LSPs............: 0

Cookies.........: 2

Browser hijacks: 0

MRU objects.....: 0

 

 

 

 

IOBIT SECURITY 360

OS:Windows XP

Version:1.0.1.30

Define Version:1211

Time Elapsed:00:16:03

Objects Scanned:74729

Threats Found:4

 

|Name|Type|Description|ID |

Tracking Cookies - Removed, Cookies, Cookie:system@m.webtrends.com/, 7-2224

Tracking Cookies - Removed, Cookies, Cookie:system@com.com/, 7-9

Trojan. Dldr - Quarantined, File, C:\System Volume Information \_ restore {3098F89E-71AC-490E-8CE0-AB45E20A1118} \RP65\A0010898.dll, 12-3356

Adware. ADON - Quarantined, File, C:\System Volume Information \_ restore {3098F89E-71AC-490E-8CE0-AB45E20A1118} \RP65\A0010899.exe, 8-1025

 

 

 

5. Quantity of additional elements as a part of the program:

IObit Security 360 - Hijack scan, Security holes, Passive Defense, Unlock And Delete, Privacy sweeper.

Ad-aware - only Privacy sweeper.

[+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 8/10]

 

6. Loading of the CENTRAL PROCESSING UNIT at IObit Security (when scanning) 360 - ~62 %. CENTRAL PROCESSING UNIT loading e Ad-Aware Free (when scanning) - ~65 %.

 

Despite, that the difference at both products small, all the same Iobit Security 360 uses CENTRAL PROCESSING UNIT resources less. [+1 to estimation IObit 360 - total 9/10]

 

 

Conclusion:

1.2 IObit Security 360 has outstripped the competitor - Ad-Aware Free, in 9 tests from ten. As should will notice that interface Iobit Security 360 is much better and more convenient, than at Ad-aware free. As should note availability of the program on a considerable quantity of languages.

 

 

 

 

Сравнительный анализ IObit Security 360 и Ad-aware (FREE)

1. Тест проводился на одноядерной машине Sempron 2600+ (1.3 Gb RAM). Место нахождения компьютера Латвия.

 

1.1 Важным элементом, на что нужно обратить внимание, это вес инсталляционного файла:

IObit Security 360 весит 8,5Mb а Ad-aware (FREE) весит 58Mb.

[ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 1/10]

 

1.2 В установленном виде IObit 360 весит 26 Mb, а Ad-aware целых 60Mb.

[ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 2/10]

2.1 Размер первого загружаемого пакета у IObit 360, занимает около 500Kb, а у Ad-aware free, более 1,5Mb.

[ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 3/10]

2.2 Пакет обнавлений у IObit Security 360 закачивается менее чем 5 секунд. А у Ad-aware free, обнавление занимает около минуты. [ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 4/10]

 

3. Скорость сканирования у IObit Security 360 (Smart scan) ~3 min. Скорость сканирования у Ad-aware free (Smart scan) ~13 min. [ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 5/10]

3.1 Скорость сканирования у IObit Security 360 (Full scan) ~16 min. Скорость сканирования у Ad-aware free (Full Scan) около 56 min. [ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 6/10]

4.1 Качество сканирования IObit Security 360 (Smart Scan) – найдено 3 угрозы безопасности (Tracking cookies). Ad-aware free (Smart Scan) найдено 4 угрозы безопасности (Tracking cookies). [ +1 к оценки AD-Aware FREE – итого 1/10]

Для наглядности приводу log файлы проверок:

AD_AWARE

Scan profile name: Smart Scan (ID: smart)

Objects scanned: 31291

Objects detected: 4

 

 

Type Detected

==========================

Processes.......: 0

Registry entries: 0

Hostfile entries: 0

Files...........: 0

Folders.........: 0

LSPs............: 0

Cookies.........: 4

Browser hijacks.: 0

MRU objects.....: 0

 

 

 

Skipped items:

Description: *atdmt* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 408910 Family ID: 0

Description: *doubleclick* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 408875 Family ID: 0

Description: *hit.gemius* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 409369 Family ID: 0

Description: *2o7* Family Name: Cookies Clean status: Success Item ID: 408943 Family ID: 0

 

 

IOBIT SECURITY 360

IObit Security 360

 

OS:Windows XP

Version:1.0.0.60

Define Version:1211

Time Elapsed:00:03:13

Objects Scanned:59723

Threats Found:3 {@doubleclick.net(*doubleclick*), @atdmt.com(*atdmt*), @msnportal.112.2o7.net(*2o7*)}

 

 

 

4.2 Качество сканирования IObit Security 360 (Full Scan) – найдено 4 угрозы безопасности (2- Tracking cookies + Adware + Trojan). Ad-aware free (Full Scan) найдено 2 угрозы безопасности (Tracking cookies). [ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 7/10]

Для наглядности приводу log файлы проверок:

 

AD_AWARE

Scan profile name: Full Scan (ID: full)

Objects scanned: 162365

Objects detected: 2

 

 

Type Detected

==========================

Processes.......: 0

Registry entries: 0

Hostfile entries: 0

Files...........: 0

Folders.........: 0

LSPs............: 0

Cookies.........: 2

Browser hijacks.: 0

MRU objects.....: 0

 

 

 

 

IOBIT SECURITY 360

OS:Windows XP

Version:1.0.1.30

Define Version:1211

Time Elapsed:00:16:03

Objects Scanned:74729

Threats Found:4

 

|Name|Type|Description|ID|

Tracking Cookies - Removed, Cookies, Cookie:system@m.webtrends.com/, 7-2224

Tracking Cookies - Removed, Cookies, Cookie:system@com.com/, 7-9

Trojan.Dldr - Quarantined, File, C:\System Volume Information\_restore{3098F89E-71AC-490E-8CE0-AB45E20A1118}\RP65\A0010898.dll, 12-3356

Adware.ADON - Quarantined, File, C:\System Volume Information\_restore{3098F89E-71AC-490E-8CE0-AB45E20A1118}\RP65\A0010899.exe, 8-1025

 

 

 

5. Количество дополнительных элементов в составе программы:

IObit Security 360 – Hijack scan, Security holes, Passive Defense, Unlock And Delete, Privacy sweeper.

Ad-aware – only Privacy sweeper.

[ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 8/10]

 

6. Загрузка ЦП у IObit Security 360 - ~62 %. Загрузка ЦП e Ad-Aware Free - ~65 %.

 

Не смотря на, то, что разница у обоих продуктов небольшая, все-таки Iobit Security 360 меньше использует ресурсы ЦП. [ +1 к оценки IObit 360 – итого 9/10]

 

 

Вывод:

IObit Security 360 опередил своего конкурента – Ad-Aware Free, в 9 тестах из десяти. Так же должен заметит, что интерфейс Iobit Security 360 намного лучше и удобнее, чем у Ad-aware free. Так же должен отметить доступность программы на большом количестве языков.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...